Should I Get A Manual Treadmill Or Automatic Treadmill?

Looking to get fit but not sure which type of treadmill to invest in? The age-old question of whether to choose a manual or automatic treadmill has puzzled many fitness enthusiasts. In this article, we aim to help you make an informed decision by outlining the key differences between the two options and highlighting the benefits and drawbacks of each. By the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of which type of treadmill is best suited to meet your fitness goals and personal preferences.

Should I Get A Manual Treadmill Or Automatic Treadmill?

Factors to Consider


When considering purchasing a treadmill, price is an important factor to consider. Manual treadmills are generally cheaper than automatic treadmills. If you’re on a tight budget, a manual treadmill may be a more affordable option for you. However, it’s important to keep in mind that manual treadmills lack certain features and functionalities that automatic treadmills offer.


The amount of space you have available in your home is another crucial consideration. Manual treadmills are usually smaller and more compact than automatic treadmills. If you live in a small apartment or have limited space, a manual treadmill may be the better choice for you. Conversely, if space is not an issue, an automatic treadmill may offer you more comfort and additional features due to their larger size.


If you need a treadmill that you can easily move around, portability is an essential factor to consider. Manual treadmills are typically lighter and easier to transport compared to their automatic counterparts. they are often foldable and can be conveniently stored away when not in use. On the other hand, automatic treadmills are generally heavier and bulkier, making them less portable. If you foresee the need to frequently move or transport your treadmill, a manual option may be the wiser choice.

Noise Level

The noise level produced by a treadmill is an important consideration, especially if you live in an apartment or have neighbors nearby. Manual treadmills tend to be quieter than automatic ones because they lack the motorized components that can generate noise. If you prefer a quieter workout experience, a manual treadmill may be more suitable for you. However, modern automatic treadmills have made significant advancements in noise reduction, so it’s worth exploring options that offer quieter operation.

Ease of Use

Speed Adjustment

The ability to adjust the speed of your treadmill is crucial to accommodate different fitness levels and workout types. Automatic treadmills generally offer a wider range of speed options, allowing for more versatility in your workouts. With the touch of a button, you can increase or decrease the speed to match your desired intensity. Manual treadmills, on the other hand, require you to keep up with the belt’s pace, which can be challenging for beginners or those looking for more precise speed control.

Incline Adjustment

Incline adjustment is another important feature to consider, as it can add variety and intensity to your workouts. Automatic treadmills often come with adjustable incline settings, allowing you to simulate uphill or downhill running. This feature can greatly enhance your cardiovascular fitness and calorie burn. Manual treadmills, however, do not have incline adjustment options, so if you’re interested in incorporating hill training into your routine, an automatic treadmill would be more suitable for you.


Belt Lubrication

One aspect of treadmill maintenance is belt lubrication. Lubricating the treadmill belt periodically helps reduce friction and keeps the machine running smoothly. Automatic treadmills usually feature built-in lubrication systems that automatically distribute lubricant to the belt. This eliminates the need for manual lubrication. With manual treadmills, you will need to regularly apply lubricant to the belt to ensure optimal performance. If simplicity and convenience are important to you, an automatic treadmill may be the better choice in terms of belt lubrication.

Electronic Components

Automatic treadmills have more electronic components compared to manual treadmills. While these components enhance the functionality and user experience, they can also require more maintenance and care. Automatic treadmills may need periodic inspections and repairs of their electronic parts, such as the console, motor, or safety features. Manual treadmills, being simpler in design, require less maintenance in terms of electronic components. If you prefer a treadmill with fewer potential maintenance issues, a manual option may be more suitable for you.

Workout Options

Pre-set Programs

Automatic treadmills often come equipped with a variety of pre-set workout programs. These programs are designed by fitness professionals to provide a diverse range of workouts targeting different goals such as weight loss, endurance, or interval training. These programs typically include various speed and incline settings, offering convenience and guidance during your workouts. Manual treadmills, however, do not offer pre-set programs, requiring you to determine and adjust the intensity of your workouts manually.

Customization Options

While manual treadmills may lack pre-set programs, they still offer customization options that allow you to tailor your workouts to your specific needs. By manually adjusting the speed and intensity, you have complete control over your workout. This can be advantageous if you have specific goals or training plans in mind. Automatic treadmills, however, provide a wider range of customization options, allowing you to adjust speed, incline, and even track your heart rate. If you prefer more guidance and a wide variety of workout options, an automatic treadmill may be a better fit for you.

Should I Get A Manual Treadmill Or Automatic Treadmill?

Safety Features

Emergency Stop Button

Safety is paramount when using any exercise equipment, and treadmills are no exception. Automatic treadmills are equipped with an emergency stop button that brings the machine to an immediate halt if needed. This feature provides a sense of security and can prevent accidents or injuries. Manual treadmills, however, do not have an emergency stop button. While they typically have a simple stop mechanism, it may take a few extra steps to come to a complete stop in case of an emergency. If safety is a top priority for you, an automatic treadmill with an emergency stop button is recommended.

Safety Key

Another safety feature offered by automatic treadmills is a safety key. This key is usually attached to the user’s clothing and acts as a safety measure. If the key is pulled or detached from the console, the treadmill will automatically stop. This feature can be particularly beneficial for those with children or pets in the house, as it helps prevent accidental use of the treadmill. Manual treadmills usually do not have a safety key feature. If you have concerns about unauthorized or accidental use, an automatic treadmill with a safety key may be the safer option for your household.

User Experience


The level of comfort during your workouts is essential for an enjoyable exercise experience. Automatic treadmills often offer more advanced cushioning systems compared to manual treadmills. These cushioning systems help absorb impact, reducing stress on joints and minimizing the risk of injuries. The running surface of automatic treadmills is typically designed for optimal shock absorption, providing a more comfortable and forgiving workout experience. Manual treadmills, on the other hand, can be more rigid, which may result in a higher impact workout. If comfort is a priority for you, an automatic treadmill with superior cushioning may be the better choice.

Smoothness of Movement

The smoothness of movement is another aspect that greatly contributes to the user experience. Automatic treadmills, with their motorized belts, generally provide a smoother and more consistent running or walking experience. The motor ensures a steady pace and eliminates the need for the user to generate their own momentum. Manual treadmills, however, rely solely on the user’s movement to keep the belt in motion. This can result in a less smooth and less fluid workout experience. If a seamless and fluid stride is important to you, an automatic treadmill may be preferable.

Fitness Goals

Weight Loss

If your primary fitness goal is weight loss, both manual and automatic treadmills can be effective. The key factor is the number of calories you burn during your workouts. Automatic treadmills often offer more workout intensity options, such as varying speed and incline settings, allowing you to achieve higher calorie burns. However, manual treadmills can also be effective for weight loss by providing a consistent and challenging workout. The extra effort required to keep the belt in motion can lead to increased calorie expenditure. Ultimately, the effectiveness of weight loss will depend on your consistency, intensity, and duration of workouts, regardless of the type of treadmill.

Cardiovascular Fitness

Improving cardiovascular fitness is a common fitness goal for many individuals. Automatic treadmills with their adjustable speed and incline options can offer a wide range of cardiovascular workouts, allowing you to reach and maintain target heart rate zones. These treadmills are designed for interval training, enabling you to alternate between high-intensity bursts and recovery periods. Manual treadmills can also provide cardiovascular benefits, but the user’s ability to maintain a consistent and challenging aerobic workout may be limited. If improving cardiovascular fitness is your primary goal, an automatic treadmill with varied workout options may be more suitable.

Muscle Strengthening

Treadmills are primarily cardio-focused exercise machines, but they can also be used to strengthen and tone muscles. Automatic treadmills often feature incline settings that target different muscle groups, such as glutes, hamstrings, and calves. By adjusting the incline, you can engage these muscles more intensively during your workout. Manual treadmills, however, may not provide the same level of targeted muscle strengthening. Nevertheless, they can still engage your leg muscles, especially if you maintain an upright posture and push against the resistance of the belt. If muscle strengthening is a key goal for you, an automatic treadmill with incline options may be more effective.

Durability and Longevity

Frame Construction

The durability and longevity of a treadmill mainly depend on its frame construction. Automatic treadmills, being larger and heavier, often utilize sturdier materials in their frames. These frames are designed to withstand the constant impact and stress of vigorous workouts. Manual treadmills, although generally lighter, can still be built with durable materials. It’s essential to choose a manual treadmill with a solid and robust frame that can handle your workout intensity. Ensure that the frame is stable and able to support your weight without wobbling or bending. If durability is a significant concern for you, consider an automatic treadmill with a well-built frame.

Motor Capacity

Automatic treadmills are equipped with motors that power the movement of the belt. The capacity and quality of the motor can significantly impact the treadmill’s performance and longevity. Higher-end automatic treadmills often have more powerful motors that provide smoother and quieter operation. These motors are built to handle continuous use and heavy-duty workouts. Manual treadmills, by design, do not have motors. While this eliminates potential motor malfunctions, it also means that the user is responsible for generating all the movement on the treadmill. The absence of a motor can make manual treadmills more durable in terms of motor-related issues. If you prioritize long-term reliability and durability, it may be worth investing in an automatic treadmill with a robust motor.

Additional Features

Built-in Speakers

Some automatic treadmills come with built-in speakers that allow you to connect your music device and enjoy your favorite tunes while working out. These speakers can enhance your workout experience and make your runs or walks more enjoyable. Connecting your music device to the treadmill eliminates the need for separate speakers or headphones, providing convenience and saving space. Manual treadmills typically do not have built-in speakers as they focus on simplicity and functionality. If you prefer to have entertainment options integrated into your treadmill, an automatic model with built-in speakers may be more appealing.

Tablet/Phone Holder

Incorporating technology into your workouts is increasingly popular. Automatic treadmills often feature a built-in tablet or phone holder, allowing you to watch videos, stream workouts, or use fitness apps while exercising. This holder keeps your device secure and at eye level, minimizing the risk of distraction or accidents. On the other hand, manual treadmills generally do not have a designated holder for electronic devices. If you enjoy using your tablet or phone during workouts or rely on fitness apps for guidance, an automatic treadmill with a tablet/phone holder can enhance your workout experience.

Consider Your Preferences

Personal Preference

Personal preference plays a significant role when choosing between a manual or automatic treadmill. Some individuals may enjoy the simplicity and challenge of a manual treadmill, while others may prefer the convenience and additional features of an automatic treadmill. Consider what you value most in a treadmill and what aligns with your fitness goals and lifestyle. It’s important to select a treadmill that will motivate and inspire you to stay consistent with your workouts. Ultimately, your personal preference should guide your decision-making process.

Weight and Fitness Level

Your weight and fitness level are important factors to consider when selecting a treadmill. Automatic treadmills typically have higher weight capacities, allowing for a wider range of users. They also offer more speed and incline options, making them suitable for varying fitness levels. Manual treadmills, although they can accommodate most users, may not be as suitable for individuals with higher body weights or those who are beginners or have limited fitness levels. It’s crucial to choose a treadmill that supports your weight and provides appropriate intensity for your current fitness level. If in doubt, consult with a fitness professional or your healthcare provider for guidance.

In conclusion, choosing between a manual treadmill and an automatic treadmill ultimately depends on your individual needs, preferences, and budget. Each type of treadmill has its advantages and disadvantages, so it’s essential to consider factors such as price, space, portability, noise level, ease of use, maintenance requirements, workout options, safety features, user experience, fitness goals, durability, and additional features. By carefully assessing these factors and aligning them with your personal preferences and fitness goals, you can make an informed decision that will help you achieve success on your fitness journey.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top